Skip to Main Content

Engineering Capstone Thesis - Completing Scoping Reviews: Step 3.1 Develop your search strategy

This guide is designed to support students completing their Engineering Captstone thesis in subject ENG561

Before you start

If you need help formulating your search strategy with Boolean operators, revisit the Engineering Research Skills guide.

Search techniques

As mentioned in Step 1, it's a good idea to do some rough preliminary searching before you start your systematic approach.

This will help you identify key authors and keywords and locate a few articles that are important to your topic. These key articles will become your "gold set" which you can not only use to identify search terms but down the track can help you test your final search strategy. If these articles don't come up when you test your strategy in the databases, you must be missing something.

You can also use your gold set for snowball searching ​- following links to citations and reference lists of an article to find related articles.

Identify concepts and keywords

Back in Step 1, you formulated your research question and may have used a search framework to help you do this. The framework (and the question itself) will direct you to the main two or three concepts you need to search. For each concept, you will need to consider all the different terms that could be used to describe it. Your knowledge of the topic along with any preliminary searching you have done will help you identify the specific search terms to use.

Think of as many terms and synonyms for each concept as you can, including:

  • both scientific and common terminology
  • alternative spellings (such as British and American spellings, and possibly common misspellings)
  • outdated and culturally-specific terms
  • abbreviations or acronyms
  • plurals
  • database-specific controlled vocabulary or thesauri (eg. SciTech and Science databases in Proquest)

For example, using the example CIMO research question we described earlier, “In disaster-prone areas, how does modular housing impact resilience to environmental stressors and reduce recovery time?"

Framework element Concept Possible search terms
C (Context) Disaster-prone areas "Disaster-prone areas" OR "High-risk regions" OR "Earthquake zones" OR "Flood-prone regions" OR "Coastal cities"
I (Intervention) Modular housing "Modular housing" OR "Prefabricated housing" OR "Temporary shelters" OR "Emergency housing" OR "Modular construction"
M (Mechanism) resilience to environmental stressors "Structural resilience" OR "Adaptability of housing" OR "Resistance to environmental stress" OR "Engineering resilience" OR "Durability of modular housing"
O (Outcome) reduced recovery time "Reduced recovery time" OR "Speed of post-disaster recovery" OR "Reconstruction timelines" OR "Disaster recovery efficiency" OR "Time to rebuild"

Once you've come up with as many specific terms as you can find, each concept will be linked with the AND operator in the final search strategy. 

Note: If you use all the elements of your search framework to combine terms, you may find you have narrowed the search too much and will struggle to find relevant studies. Try using only the most critical elements from the framework. For example, in a CIMO search, you would often exclude the O (outcome) terms in your search strategy. If the M (mechanism) is the status quo, you wouldn't use those terms either. 

Identify search limits/exclusions

It's important for any literature search to consider the limitations of your search. For scoping reviews, you must establish the boundaries very early on. Which studies will be excluded from the review and why? 

For a scoping review, information about the inclusion and exclusion criteria is usually recorded as a paragraph or table in the methods section.

Common criteria include:

  • Time period - Perhaps there has been a previous review and this is an update, so included articles may be only those published since the previous review.
  • Language - It is not usually necessary to arrange for translations of articles published only in other languages.
  • Publication type - Usually you will only be looking for original studies, so you may consider excluding editorials and letters.
  • Geography or setting - You may need to limit the review to a particular population group, or a particular setting (eg. school or hospital).
  • Age groups - Many databases include particular age groups as subject headings or limits if this is relevant to your research question.
  • Study design - Consider including specific study designs, such as controlled trials or qualitative studies, if that is applicable to your question. This could be a way of making a broad review more manageable.

Get better search results

Check your understanding

Charles Sturt University acknowledges the traditional custodians of the lands on which its campuses are located, paying respect to Elders, both past and present, and extend that respect to all First Nations Peoples.Acknowledgement of Country

Charles Sturt University is an Australian University, TEQSA Provider Identification: PRV12018. CRICOS Provider: 00005F.